Titles: The Declaration, The Resistance, The Legacy
Series: The Declaration
Author: Gemma Malley
Publisher: Bloomsbury USA Children
Rating: 3/5
Pitch:
Sixteen-year-old Anna should not have been born. It is the year 2140 and people can live for ever. No one wants another mouth to feed, so she lives in a Surplus Hall, where unwanted children go to learn valuable lessons . . . at least she wasn't put down at birth.One day, a new inmate arrives. Anna's life is thrown into chaos. He says things about her parents and the Outside that couldn't possibly be true . . . Or could they?(Goodreads)
My review :
For
once, I'll talk about all three books at the same time. Since I read
the three one after another in the same book and since, overall, they
have the same strength and weaknesses, might as well do them at the same
time instead of repeating the same things.
I
didn't like the characters. None of them. Neither Peter, nor Anna, nor
Paul, nor anyone. Anna is annoying at best and she needs a shot of
adrenaline or a few slaps across the face. Peter is a living cliché of
the wannabe-hero who doesn't think more than needed. The others are like
cardboard figures in a puppet theatre. They don't have enough substance
to live outside the purpose the author created for them.
The
construction of the books is similar for the three. The beginning is
long, almost boring. In the first book it was rather hard to live. I had
the impression of pedaling in the mud before it really started. In the
other two, curiosity kept me going.
The
ending of the books wasn't that bad. The ending of the first one made
me laugh (I guess it was supposed to be tragic but all just came
together so neatly at the last moment that it was just hilarious). The
second one's was nice. The third's made me laugh too because was well
done. I liked it.
Other
than that... The story is original and if the characters had been
better, it would have been real good. Moreover, some parts were so long
and difficult, and the clichés, the plot twists too easy... The book has
its own strength and weaknesses but the reading wasn't any less good.
It's not the worst nor the best dystopia I read. For the summer, it's
still quite nice and not so bad and it's enough.

Commentaires
Enregistrer un commentaire